A SIRE 2.0 negative observation does not end at the closing meeting. Each one is coded, published to the SIRE database and read by charterers for the next 12 months, and the next inspector may look at the same area again. This guide covers how observations are coded with SOC, NOC and PIF, how to use the 14-day comment window, and how to track corrective action with evidence until it is closed. Book a demo to see observation tracking in action.

SIRE 2.0 · after the inspection

SIRE 2.0 negative observations: close the loop before the next vet

Every observation follows the same path. The work is making sure each one reaches the end.

1RecordedInspector codes SOC, NOC, PIF
2ReleasedReport reaches the operator
3Commented14-day initial window
4CorrectedRoot cause and action
5EvidencedDated proof attached
6ClosedVerified before the next vet

Anatomy of a SIRE 2.0 negative observation: SOC, NOC and PIF

SIRE 2.0 questions are answered with up to three response tools: hardware, process and human. A negative response is recorded in the negative observation module with a subject of concern (SOC) and a nature of concern (NOC). A negative human response also carries at least one performance influencing factor (PIF). The example below is illustrative.

Human responseQ 5.x (example)

Officer of the watch could not describe the steps for isolating equipment before maintenance under the permit to work.

SOCSubject: who or what the concern is about
NOCNature: what was wrong
PIFWhy it happened, such as custom and practice

Why the coding matters

Coded findings can be compared and searched across a ship’s history and across fleets. Charterers and your own office can see patterns, such as the same NOC appearing again on another ship.

One defect, several observations

Anglo-Eastern reports that a single issue has produced up to six observations across hardware, process and human tools. Track each observation separately, even when one fix covers several.

PIF attribution: aim corrective action at the real cause

The PIF tells you why the crew response fell short, so it should decide what kind of corrective action you take. SIRE 2.0 uses nine PIFs. The corrective action focus shown for each is a suggested starting point, not OCIMF guidance.

Custom and practiceCoach the procedure on board; check work as done32.9%
Recognition of safety criticalityExplain the hazard behind the step, not only the step30.3%
Opportunities to learn and practiseDrills and hands-on practice12.1%
Procedure accessibility and accuracySimplify or correct the SMS procedure
Team dynamics and communicationBriefings, closed-loop communication
Workload and fatigueReview manning, hours and task planning
StressLook at the conditions behind the task
Morale and motivationFeedback and recognition on board
Workplace ergonomics and HMILayout, labelling and equipment interfaces

Shares of PIF attributions from the INTERTANKO SIRE 2.0 benchmarking statistics for 2025 (7,241 inspections), as reported by Maritime Trainer, which also gives human factors as 37% of negative observations. Some sources list ergonomics and human-machine interface separately.

The 14-day window: operator comments on each observation

OCIMF gives the operator 14 days from when the report is processed to add initial comments. If none are added, the report publishes automatically without them. Later comments can be added at any time while the report is available. For a wider view of reducing findings, see our guide to reducing SIRE 2.0 negative observations.

Days 1–3Triage
Days 4–10Root cause and plan
Days 11–14Review and post
Day 14Auto-publish
Say what you didImmediate action, root cause and corrective action, with dates.
Stay factualComments are read by charterers. Avoid arguing with the inspector; inspectors do not review comments.
Add a later commentWhen the action closes, post a short follow-up with the closure date.

Suggested split of the 14 days is illustrative. Factual errors in a draft report are handled separately through the report validation process.

Use all 14 days, not the last one

Turn each observation into a task with an owner, a due date and an evidence slot the day the report arrives.

Remediation evidence: what closes an observation

A closed task without proof is an open question at the next vet. Evidence should be dated, specific to the finding and easy to find. Our guide to SIRE 2.0 photo evidence covers photo practice in detail.

Weak
  • “Crew reminded” with no record
  • Undated photo of the area
  • Generic circular to the fleet
  • Task closed by the person who raised it
Strong
  • Timestamped before and after photos
  • Signed training or drill record with names
  • Revised procedure with version and date
  • Close-out checked by the office or a superintendent

Corrective action tracking: fields for every observation

Keep one record per observation, linked to the report. These fields cover what charterers, auditors and the next inspector may ask.

FieldWhat to recordWhy
ReferenceReport, question number and observation textLinks the action to the published finding
CodingResponse tool, SOC, NOC, PIFLets you spot repeats across the fleet
Immediate actionWhat was done on board, with dateShows the risk was controlled
Root causeAnalysis such as 5-Why, tied to the PIFStops the same finding returning
Corrective actionMeasurable action, owner, due dateClear responsibility
Preventive actionSMS, PMS or training change, fleet-wide if relevantProtects sister ships
EvidenceTimestamped files attached to the recordProof at the next vet
VerificationWho checked closure, and whenIndependent close-out

Closing the 12-month observation loop

OCIMF keeps a report active on the SIRE database for 12 months, during which charterers can read the observations and your comments. OCIMF does not set inspection frequency; each charterer applies its own criteria, and many look for a recent inspection. Plan closure well inside the window.

Month 0Report published
Month 1Most actions closed
Month 3Fleet checks done
Month 5Ready for next request
Month 12Report no longer active

Milestones are illustrative targets, not OCIMF requirements.

Watch for repeats

Kaiko Systems fleet data, cited in our reduction guide, found about one in four observations had already been raised on the same ship. A repeat finding suggests the earlier corrective action did not hold.

Manage open defects properly

Anglo-Eastern notes that OCIMF has stated defects handled under a proper defect management process should not lead to negative observations. Keep a current open defect list ready to present.

Share across the fleet

A NOC on one ship is a check for every sister ship. Our fleet-wide SIRE 2.0 readiness guide covers this.

SIRE 2.0 remediation checklist

Run this for every published report.

How Marine Inspection tracks SIRE 2.0 corrective actions

Marine Inspection turns each observation into a tracked task with coding, an owner, a due date and attached evidence, and moves it through review to verified closure. The board below is illustrative.

SIRE 2.0 observations · MV example · report day 95 open · 2 closed

Open 2

Human · PIF custom and practicePTW isolation stepsDue day 14
ProcessChecklist version on bridgeDue day 12

In action 2

HardwareDeck seal corrosionSpares ordered
Human · PIF learningGas detector useDrill booked

Evidence review 1

ProcessPermit log gaps3 files attached

Verified 2

HardwareFire door closerClosed day 6
ProcessOpen defect listClosed day 4
Timestamped photo evidenceOwner and due date alertsFleet-wide repeat searchVerification sign-off

SIRE 2.0 negative observation FAQs

What are SOC and NOC in SIRE 2.0?

Subject of concern and nature of concern. Inspectors use them to code a negative response in the negative observation module: what the concern is about and what was wrong.

What is PIF attribution?

For a negative human response, the inspector links at least one of nine performance influencing factors that explains why the task fell short, such as custom and practice.

How long do operators have to comment?

OCIMF gives 14 days from when the report is processed for initial comments. After that the report publishes automatically, and later comments can still be added.

How long do observations stay visible?

A report stays active on the SIRE database for 12 months, so its observations and your comments can be read by charterers during that time.

What counts as good remediation evidence?

Dated, specific proof: timestamped before and after photos, signed training records, revised procedures with version dates, and an independent close-out check.

Can Marine Inspection track observations across a fleet?

Yes. Start a free trial to log observations, assign actions and attach evidence per ship.

Close every observation with proof

Code it, own it, fix the cause and attach the evidence, so the next inspector finds the loop already closed.